Licence to Kill
Sunday Times (London)
February 21, 1999
The vast war crimes committed during the
20th century remain its greatest mystery, a
moral and psychological black hole that
swallows all pity and remorse, and leaves
behind a void that will haunt the next
millennium. I shuddered over each page of
this heart-rending book, but strongly urge
everyone to read it. Meticulously researched
and written in a tone of barely contained
anger, it serves as a warning to those who
believe that Belsen and the Burma-Siam
railway could never happen again.
How could Japan and Germany, two of the most
advanced nations on our planet, have
unleashed wars of ferocious barbarity
against their neighbours, murdering millions
of civilians in the most cruel and savage
way? How could these same peoples, only a
few years later, sharing the same airliners
with us and strolling around the same
museums, seem virtually indistinguishable
from ourselves, as kindly and generous to
strangers?
Genocide, for Europeans and Americans, is
almost a German monopoly, but Iris Chang
points out that mass murder was carried out
systematically by the Japanese invaders of
China long before the first gas chambers
were built at Auschwitz. During the
Sino-Japanese war, from 1937 to 1945, the
Japanese army killed at least 10m Chinese
civilians. Yet few of those responsible,
from foot soldiers to general staff, were
ever punished or showed the slightest
regret. Chang brings together a huge body of
eye-witness accounts, war crimes testimonies
and personal reminiscences which have
appeared in scattered form throughout the
past 50 years.
In August 1937, Japanese forces invaded
China, swiftly seizing the main coastal
cities. For three months fierce fighting
raged around Shanghai, and my own family,
who lived outside the British-run
International Settlement, left for the
French Concession, a safe haven from the
fighting, when shells from rival Chinese and
Japanese artillery guns began to fly over
our roof. Tens of thousands of Chinese
civilians were killed in the fighting, as we
saw when we later drove out to the silent
battlefields.
I remember the procession of
chauffeur-driven Packards and Buicks that
stopped near a devastated village, and the
hundreds of dead Chinese lying by the
roadside and in the abandoned paddy fields.
Wearing their silk dresses, my mother and
the other wives stepped with their husbands
among the bright cartridge cases, a sight
that even at the age of seven struck me as
bizarre.
That November, after laying waste to the
Yangtze plain, the Japanese armies launched
their attack on Nanking, then the capital of
China. When the city fell on December 13,
the triumphant Japanese soldiers unleashed
an orgy of murder, rape and torture that
lasted for six weeks and killed more than
300,000 Chinese civilians, shocking even the
German Nazi party members who were resident
in the city.
The 90,000 Chinese soldiers who surrendered
were quickly rounded up, roped together and
moved to improvised killing grounds outside
the city, where they were shot, beheaded,
used for human bayonet practice or soaked
with petrol and burnt alive. Mounds of
Chinese corpses formed huge dykes along the
Yangtze. All this was photographed by
Japanese reporters, and one newspaper ran an
illustrated article about the friendly
rivalry between two officers under the
heading "Contest to kill first 100 Chinese
by beheading".
Once all military opposition was out of the
way, the Japanese soldiers turned on the
city's civilians. For the next six weeks
they moved from house to house, bayonetting
the men and raping the women, from girls as
young as eight to grandmothers in their
seventies. After they were raped most were
killed. One former soldier, Azuma Shiro,
recently testified: "We always stabbed and
killed them . . . When we were raping her,
we looked at her as a woman, but when we
killed her we thought of her as something
like a pig."
Sadistic torments were devised, involving
live burials, castrations, disembowellings,
and the forcing of Chinese parents to have
sex with their children before they were
killed. Mutilated corpses rotted in the
streets. Amazingly, much of this was
documented in photographs, many of which are
reproduced in Chang's horrific account. If
these chilling images, a true pornography of
death, help to sell this book they will have
served their purpose.
A few of the new recruits to this orgy of
killing were shaken by what they saw, but
they soon became desensitised and willingly
joined in. An officer named Tominaga was
stunned when he first met the men under his
command. "They had evil eyes. They weren't
human eyes, but the eyes of leopards or
tigers." He quickly turned into a killing
machine, using emaciated Chinese prisoners
for beheading and bayonet practice, and
noticed that his men's eyes no longer seemed
evil. He said: "Everyone became a demon
within three months."
A Japanese veteran from Nanking, Dr
Nagatomi, is one of the few to express
remorse. "I beheaded people, starved them to
death, burned them, buried them alive, over
200 in all . . . There are really no words
to describe what I was doing. I was truly a
devil."
But why did he become a sadistic murderer,
and why did hundreds of thousands of
Japanese soldiers turn into a horde of
conscienceless killers? Chang, an American
historian whose parents narrowly escaped
death in Nanking (they fled to Taiwan and
then became academics in America), blames
the brutalities of the Japanese army and the
long-standing racial hatred of the Chinese,
seen as an inferior people little better
than animals. When we try to make sense of
Nazi crimes, we blame a small group of
political gangsters (Hitler and the
Nuremberg defendants) and their SS murder
squads, together driven by deeply
psychopathic racial hatreds. But historians
have confirmed what many people suspected,
that millions of Germans in army and police
regiments were involved in the mass murder
of civilians.
Were they all psychopaths? I suspect that
none, or few, of them were. During the long
Japanese occupation of Shanghai we witnessed
countless atrocities against Chinese
civilians. After the Japanese attack of
Pearl Harbor, in December 1941, my family
and I, along with other Allied nationals,
had been interned in Lunghua camp near
Shanghai. In August 1945, a few days after
the war had officially ended, I was walking
from the camp and came across a unit of
Japanese soldiers at a wayside railway
station. One of them, who was slowly
strangling a Chinese youth with telephone
wire, shouted at me. He had noticed my
transparent celluloid belt, which I had
wheedled from an American sailor. A long
haggle went on, which ended with me
unbuckling my precious belt. I remember the
soldier's intense pleasure in his new
possession as he went back to killing the
Chinese, and my own deep sense of loss.
Was he a psychopath? I seriously doubt it.
The real horror of this century's war crimes
is that they were carried out by ordinary
human beings, farmers and factory workers
and office clerks, who returned to their
jobs and brought up their children. Faced
with a threat to themselves, human beings
become cruel and dangerous, and the murder
and torture of enemy civilians is an unhappy
part of their natural behaviour, only
restrained by the prevailing moral codes,
the political leadership and the officers in
charge. When rulers and generals urge on
racial war, ordinary soldiers become their
core selves, as vicious as the chimpanzee
raiding parties who work themselves up with
blood-curdling screams and tear the enemy
limb from limb. I hope that the Japanese
soldier at the railway station went on to
become the remorseful Dr Nagatomi.
-------------
J. G. Ballard is the author of the autobiographical EMPIRE OF THE SUN, later adapted into a film by Steven Spielberg. He also wrote CRASH, which became a controversial movie starring Holly Hunter and James Spader.